San Francisco 49ers In Turmoil - The Saga Of Head Coach Mike Singletary and Owner Jed York

The 49ers have seen their season get uglier by the week, which has led to rumblings that Coach Singletary is on the hot seat. We'll provide you with updates throughout the season. For fan reaction, check out Niners Nation.

  • Live
2 Total Updates since October 11, 2010
  • Updates 2
  • All Updates 2

Mike Singletary And Alex Smith, Jumping The Gun On The End Of An Era

No, not "error," Dick Stockton, I actually mean the word "era."

So we all know that the 49ers have a slew of issues from top to bottom. The very fact that this Story Stream exists at all tells even the most casual of fans that something is definitely awry in the 49ers organization. Something has got to give, short of a miraculous turn-around, be it front office or personnel. Or, if you wanted me to get with some owner-lingo, we'll be dealing with some "private personal personnel," matters. You know the ones, 49ers fans.

What is it, though, that is most likely to give? I doubt the young-and-eager "protégé," of Eddie D. is going to sign-off on his own pink slip and take a measure of blame, so we'll assume it's something below the mark of "owner-in-training," that will give. From there we have people like Paraag Marathe, a good friend of Jed's and the like. Under that mess we have head coach Mike Singletary, who himself forced something to give earlier in the season when he fired offensive coordinator Jimmy Raye in favor of then-quarterbacks coach Mike Johnson. Greg Manusky is in the discussion as well, having himself a rare bad season as defensive coordinator. His defense has crumbled a few notable times this season, and found a way to fumble a win away in Atlanta.

While I'm sure we'll speculate much further on such things regarding who will get the axe, if indeed anyone must be done away with, I'll settle on some recent bits from one of the other Bay Area writers: Tim Kawakami. Kawakami has struck early, and if you keep up with his Talking Points blog, he's striking often.

The quarterback - coach tandem of Alex Smith and Mike Singletary is coming to an explosive end, says Kawakami. He begins the article with a very level-headed look at the upcoming schedule and the difficulties the 49ers will be presented with in picking up actual, factual wins. It's a very apt statement, considering where the team stands now at 0-5. Most fans weren't predicting a hugely stellar record at this point in the season, 3-2 was the hot pick, with wins over Philly, Seattle and Kansas City. They would take two tough losses early in the season, but come back strong against the weaker competition. That's what the plan was, the scheme to get by and win the NFC West.

Those eleven games are looking more difficult by the day. Games against Green Bay and San Diego were seen as tough matchups, but not something insurmountable. Everything else would be cake, before the season started. Now, the pseudo-home game against the Broncos and even the week six non-home advantage at home against the Oakland Raiders is tough as well.

But back to Kawakami's point:

That sideline spat between QB and coach was the public moment that both men decided it was over.    

This bit is almost undoubtedly true. While Smith is probably going to start the rest of the season, one can assume that the 49ers will pursue other avenues for their quarterback position in 2011. So the tandem of the two is essentially over. But does that mean both are gone from the organization? Does that mean Singletary doesn't return in 2011?

That's the "maybe," from me, personally. While it's not like he's done anything special this year, I feel that the organization and a sizable portion of the fanbase are still behind Sing. They're not angry, Coach, they're just disappointed. They don't much like the fact that you're still dabbling in Alex Smith, and they want you to end the relationship post-haste. For them. For us.

There's a bit about the team needing an offensive-minded coach and things of that nature, and they are certainly apt, no doubt. The comments hold water, much like most of what Tim says, even if the majority don't agree with him. It's taken an 0-5 start for me to raise a pitchfork along with him, but I'm not going to raise it against Singletary. You don't necessarily need to switch to an offensive-minded coach, you just need to have some semblance of competence in your offensive support staff.

Personal opinions aside, there's generally some possibility of things happening if someone knowledgeable about a situation believes that they will. I've been right before, and Kawakami has been right before. Mike Singletary could very well be on the hot seat just as much as Alex Smith is. They could both be attached at the hip, as CSN Bay Area's Matt Maiocco noted. Or maybe Smith is just riding shotgun, and Singletary is driving one of those sweet spy cars and can eject Smith's seat out the roof of the car. It's possible ...

Continue

San Francisco 49ers In Turmoil - The Saga Of Head Coach Mike Singletary and Owner Jed York

Over the past five weeks the San Francisco 49ers have seen their season crumble in front of their very eyes. The team lost to the Philadelphia Eagles yesterday to fall to 0-5 and the boo birds were out in force during Alex Smith's struggles calling for everything from David Carr to Eddie Debartolo.


Although Alex Smith did show some moxie coming back from the booing to throw a pair of touchdowns, it wasn't enough as the 49ers lost 27-24 to the Eagles. Things got even more interesting that evening as Jed York texted ESPN stating that the 49ers would win the NFC West. This came on the heels of an appearance on NBC's Press Here in which he stated that Mike Singletary's job was safe.

View more news videos at: http://www.nbcbayarea.com/video.


What is interesting about this is that when he's asked what is his threshold, he said, "Let's win against Philadelphia." Given that the team did not in fact win that game, that would certainly seem to push Coach Singletary a bit closer to the hot seat. Whatever the case, when an owner starts talking about a coach's job security, that's exactly when it's clear the coach's job is not quite so secure.

Given how spectacularly things have imploded thus far, this is clearly going to be a running story the rest of this season. Whether the 49ers make any sort of coaching change or not, we'll be here to provide updates on the turmoil within the 49ers organization. Even if no major event takes place, there is plenty of media commentary to provide on this volatile situation.

Continue
X
Log In Sign Up

forgot?
Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

Join SB Nation Bay Area

You must be a member of SB Nation Bay Area to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at SB Nation Bay Area. You should read them.

Join SB Nation Bay Area

You must be a member of SB Nation Bay Area to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at SB Nation Bay Area. You should read them.

Spinner

Authenticating

Great!

Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.